How It's Made
When making wine, "you're basically converting sugar to alcohol," says Rodney Schatz, a third-generation grape farmer and chairman of the California Association of Winegrape Growers. To make red wine, red grapes are harvested at a certain Brix level, which indicates the percentage of sugar in the grape. Grapes are then crushed and left to ferment in a tank with added yeasts. To extract the desired tannins, colors, and flavors, temperature is controlled and the speed of fermentation is manipulated as juice is pumped over the skins.
White winemaking applies the same basic process as that of red wine, except the grape skins are removed before fermentation. "You're not looking for flavor from the skin, as you are with the red," explains Schatz. "You're looking for more flavor from the meat of the grape."
To make sparkling wine, such as Champagne, "you're taking finished wine and you're refermenting it," says Schatz. During the normal fermentation process, carbon dioxide is naturally given off to the air. During the second fermentation of sparkling wine in the bottle, the carbon dioxide is not released, giving the drink its natural effervescence.
Red vs. White vs. Sparkling
Red wine naturally contains phytochemicals. Two types of polyphenols — catechins and resveratrol, found in the skin and seeds of grapes — are thought to give red wine its antioxidant heart-healthy properties. The antioxidants in wine, called flavonoids, also reduce the risk of coronary heart disease by reducing bad LDL cholesterol, boosting good HDL cholesterol, and reducing blood clotting. One study even suggests that resveratrol may inhibit tumor growth for some cancers.
So how do all the different wines stack up against each other? "Red has more antioxidants than white, rose has similar to red, and there's not really any antioxidants in Champagne," says Lisa Young, adjunct professor of nutrition at New York University and author of The Portion Teller Plan. Since polyphenol level is rooted in the grape skin, red wine holds superior to lighter-tinted wines — though white wine does have some cardio-protective benefits. But while their antioxidant count is diminished, white wines retain the ability to reduce bad LDL cholesterol.
The Health Risks Involved
Before you think wine's antioxidant properties are reason enough to toast every celebration, know this: In September of 2007, U.S. researchers announced that an average of three or more drinks a day — be it wine, beer, or hard alcohol — can raise a woman's risk of breast cancer as much as smoking a pack of cigarettes. Ethyl alcohol, present in all booze, is the suspected culprit. Studies showed that women who consumed one or two drinks a day upped their risk for breast cancer by 10 percent, while those who consumed three or more drinks a day raised their risk by as much as 30 percent.
Wine takes the prize as one of the lowest-calorie alcoholic beverages per serving. For a 5-ounce serving, red wine rings in at approximately 105 calories. White wine contains about 100. Three ounces of dessert wine, on the other hand, racks up 141 calories — so continue to mind your after-dinner drink count.
If you're really watching your waistline, consider cutting calories with a wine spritzer. "If you mix wine with sparkling water, which has zero calories, in a way you're getting more bang for your buck," says Young. Twice the drink for the same number of calories? Sign us up!
So, Glass Half Empty or Half Full?
The bottom line: When it comes to drinking for your health, moderation is key. The USDA defines moderation as up to one drink a day for women. In the case of wine, that means 5 ounces.
And teetotalers don't have to miss out on the heart-healthy benefits just for staying dry. "You don't have to drink red wine; you can have the grapes, too," Young explains. In fact, one study indicated that purple grape juice offers the same heart-healthy benefits as red wine.
Originally published on FitnessMagazine.com, November 2007.